Amateurish mistakes are being made by websites who normally do better such as Wired describing Collective Shout as a ‘conservative’ organization. Even in the most extremes of American conservativism, you will hear them attempting to legally restrict or chill speech. The reason why is because American conservatives are the most censored. In fact, they try to do as much as they can to encourage speech. As Rush Limbaugh used to say, “We want them to tell us who they are.”
Collective Shout is a feminist organization.
Collective Shout began in 2009, co-founded by self-described “pro-life feminist” Melinda Tankard Reist. Collective Shout describes itself as “A grassroots campaigning movement against the objectification of women and sexualization of girls in media, advertising, and popular culture”. To date, it has been involved in:
- Unsuccessful efforts to ban Snoop Dogg and Eminem from Australia.
- A successful 2015 campaign to prevent Tyler the Creator from touring Australia.
- A successful 2015 campaign to pressure Target and Kmart to stop selling Grand Theft Auto 5 in Australia.
- A petition to ban the game No Mercy from sale, which ultimately led to the developers pulling it from Steam.
- An unsuccessful petition to ban Detroit: Become Human from sale in Australia.
On July 7, Collective Shout shared an update to its No Mercy Change.org campaign calling on supports to email payment processors (including PayPal, MasterCard, Visa, and Discover) to demand that they “cut ties with Steam and itch.io” over “hundreds of r*pe, incest, and child-abuse games.” This was followed by an open letter from Collective Shout asking that they “immediately cease processing payments on Steam and itch.io and any other platforms hosting similar games.”
I’m not familiar with Australian laws and don’t really care. They don’t have any power to stop the speech of it, only the financial transactions. If the games were released for free, Collective Shout can do nothing about it. And if the games were released for free, there could be other ways for the creator to get money.
In other words, Collective Shout cannot shut down this blog. And I objectify women all the time. You know why? Because they love it! I’ve never met a woman who didn’t want to be objectified. If I ever want to read about a woman being raped, I’d just read female written literature. They love the stuff! It’s not men who made 50 Shades of Grey.
Men do not want to demean women. It’s not in man’s nature. Women demean themselves by their conduct, their clothing, their tattoos, their strange piercings, etc. If man had his way, women wouldn’t destroy themselves. Women wouldn’t be eating bad food and getting fat. Women wouldn’t be dying their hair blue.
This tactic Collective Shout is doing isn’t changing anyone’s minds or hearts. All it is doing is having people seek an alternative work around to the credit processors. And then, once again, the floodgates will be back open. Human nature isn’t going to change.
Up through the 1990s and maybe early 2000s, video games always were criticized for being ‘violent’ and ‘inciting violence’. For some reason, this went away. Now, the criticism is that the games are too ‘sexy’ and somehow ‘hurting women’.
Women will be the ones taking down Collective Shout.
Politics do tend to change over the centuries. People forget that we are a quarter done with the twenty first century. One thing that is arising in different countries is a female supremist movement. The male gays get grouped in with their attacks. Why? Because everything for male gays is considered anti-woman because none of it is about women. The future politics is not going to be labor vs owners or north vs south or even liberal vs conservative. It is going to be women vs men. Men can end it in a second if they just take to arms.
Collective Shout would have some credibility if it also went after entertainment that women consumed or profited. But it doesn’t. You don’t see Collective Shout going after Only Fans for example.
You must be logged in to post a comment.